Single Drum Roller vs Double Drum Roller: How to Choose the Right Compaction Roller
Single Drum Roller vs Double Drum Roller: How to Choose the Right Compactor
Reading time: 6 min
Whether you’re laying the groundwork for a new sidewalk or setting down miles of new highway, a compaction roller can help you achieve a flat, stable surface.
Known by various names, such as road rollers, drum rollers or compactors, these machines are crucial for putting the finishing touches on construction and paving endeavors. They efficiently compact loose materials, removing pockets of air and increasing the density of the target surface.
One common type of compaction roller is a static, or smooth-wheeled roller. Static rollers feature large, smooth drums that use the weight of the machine itself to exert pressure on the ground.
Static rollers can be used on a wide variety of surfaces, including soil, gravel, sand and asphalt. Compared to handheld compaction equipment, static rollers are far more efficient, reducing the time and labor required to compact large surface areas.
Most static rollers feature either a single drum at the front of the machine or two drums–one at the front and one at the rear.
Static rollers with a single drum, called single drum rollers, feature a pair of pneumatic tires that drive the machine forward. By contrast, a double-drum roller does not have tires at all; it simply rolls forward or backward on the machine’s drums.
In this guide, we’ll take an in-depth look at the differences between single and double-drum rollers. We’ll cover the advantages of each type of machine, and what you should consider before purchasing or renting one for your next project.
Driver operating a single drum padfoot roller.
Single Drum Rollers: An In-depth Look
A single drum roller is characterized by its singular large drum, which serves as the primary compaction element. This drum is typically smooth, and its weight plays a key role in helping it achieve compaction.
Since single drum rollers have a pair of pneumatic tires, they are more versatile and maneuverable than their double-drum counterparts. A single drum roller’s tires make it better suited for navigating tight spaces and handling slopes and inclines.
Here are some of the key advantages of using a single drum roller:
- Enhanced maneuverability. Single drum rollers are preferred whenever maneuverability is a concern. Since they have a pair of tires, they can be moved in and out of tight spaces with relative ease. They also tend to be smaller, which helps them fit in cramped spaces.
- Improved operator visibility. Compared to double drum rollers, the operator in a single drum roller is seated higher up on the machine. This provides operators with improved visibility, helping them navigate the work site efficiently.
- Better traction. Since single drum rollers feature tires, they tend to have better traction than double drum rollers. This is particularly useful if you are working on sloped or uneven terrain where enhanced traction is required.
- More versatility. Single drum rollers can be used on a wider variety of projects. Since they are compact and easy to maneuver, they can be used on driveways, sidewalks and landscaping projects.
Double Drum roller located in an equipment yard.
Double Drum Rollers: An In-depth Look
Double drum rollers feature a pair of two drums mounted to a single chassis. The operator cab of a double drum roller is seated between the two drums.
Although they are less versatile and more difficult to maneuver, double drum rollers are more efficient than single drum rollers. Because they feature two drums, each pass with the double drum roller is like making two passes with a single drum roller.
Here are the benefits of using a double drum roller:
- Superior efficiency. The main advantage of using a double drum roller is its superior efficiency. Since double drum rollers have twice as many drums as single drum rollers, they can compact the same surface area in half as many passes, saving on fuel, operator hours and other resources.
- More powerful. Not only do double drum rollers offer improved efficiency, they are more powerful. Double drum rollers are typically larger and weigh more than single drum rollers. They also feature powerful engines that are more capable and dynamic.
- Better for large projects. For large-scale construction projects where speed is a concern, such as compacting roads, highways and large parking lots, double drum rollers are superior to single drum rollers. What they lack in maneuverability, they make up for in speed, allowing operators to compact large surface areas in a short amount of time.
Single Drum vs. Double Drum Roller: Which Should You Choose?
When deciding between a single drum roller or a double drum roller, it’s important to consider your particular application. In most cases, the decision comes down to a trade off between maneuverability and output. While single drum rollers are more compact and maneuverable, double drum rollers are capable of greater output.
If your project requires a high degree of maneuverability, such as a landscaping project or constructing a driveway, then your needs will be better served by a single drum roller. Single drum rollers may also represent a better investment if you plan on purchasing the roller. Since they are more versatile, a single drum roller will have a wider variety of uses, especially for small/medium sized projects.
On the other hand, if your project is in a wide open area where the roller only needs to roll forward and backward, a double drum roller represents a more efficient alternative. Double drum rollers are powerful, efficient and ideal for large-scale projects like building highways and parking lots.
Maintenance Considerations
In addition to differences in performance, single drum rollers and double drum rollers also have varying maintenance needs.
Since a double drum roller has two drums, it may require more maintenance than a single drum roller. Drums are equipped with watering systems, and the components of the watering system will need to be maintained. Drums also need to be properly lubricated, so a double drum roller will need twice as much attention in this regard.
Final Thoughts
Deciding between a single drum roller or a double drum roller can be tricky. By choosing the type of roller that most closely aligns with the needs of your particular application, you can maximize your efficiency and avoid going over budget.
For all of your compact roller maintenance needs, be sure to check out the EquipmentShare Shop. Our extensive parts catalog features OEM and aftermarket parts for single drum rollers and double drum rollers, helping you keep your machines rolling along. If you’re having trouble locating a part, reach out to our parts experts and get customized help.
Back to About Machines
Are you signed up for our newsletter?
We'll send you a monthly email covering everything from specialty parts to machine overviews, packed with tons of knowledge from our industry pros and no filler.
SIGN UP →
