The Benefits of Conducting Heavy Equipment Maintenance vs Replacing Equipment Altogether

Reading time: 6 min

Home > Machine Maintenance

Heavy equipment downtime in the construction industry can significantly disrupt project timelines and increase overall costs. When machinery is inoperable, work comes to a standstill, leading to delays that can affect the entire project schedule and incur additional labor charges. Moreover, the costs of emergency repairs are often higher than routine maintenance.

Proper machine maintenance minimizes downtime by ensuring machines are in optimal working condition. Regular maintenance checks can identify potential issues early on, allowing for preventive measures to avoid costly breakdowns. This approach not only extends the lifespan of the machinery, ensuring a better return on investment but also enhances reliability and efficiency on the job site, ultimately reducing costs and improving productivity.

What is Heavy Equipment Maintenance

There are two fundamental approaches to heavy equipment maintenance: preventive and reactive. Preventive maintenance focuses on regular inspections and servicing to prevent breakdowns. This includes oil changes, lubrication and filter replacements, among other tasks. On the other hand, reactive maintenance occurs post-failure, requiring immediate repairs to restore functionality, like engine overhauls or fixing hydraulic systems.

Why Should You Conduct Heavy Equipment Maintenance Rather Than Replace Your Machine?

Maintaining current equipment saves costs, preserving capital for other investments. It avoids high costs of new purchases and depreciation. Staying familiar with existing machinery streamlines routine maintenance and reduces training time while ensuring reliable performance.

Replacing Heavy Equipment: New vs Used Equipment

When it comes to purchasing heavy equipment, costs can vary greatly depending on factors such as size, horsepower and intended use. Smaller models designed for lighter tasks are generally much more affordable, while larger machines built for demanding applications, like mining or large-scale construction, can represent a far greater investment.

Opting for a used machine can offer substantial savings and allow for more negotiation in price, although these machines might lack some of the latest features found in new models.

New machines typically depreciate faster than used ones. In the first few years after purchase, new equipment often loses a substantial portion of its value. Used machines have already absorbed this initial depreciation and tend to decline in value more gradually over time.

Why You Should Consider Rebuilding Instead of Replacement

Heavy machinery repair involves fixing specific faults or components to restore functionality quickly. In contrast, a machine rebuild is more comprehensive; involving complete disassembly, inspection and replacement or refurbishment of multiple parts. This essentially renews the machine to extend its lifespan significantly, sometimes increasing its total usable hours by 50-100%. Although major rebuilds are more extensive and time-consuming than repairs, they are still only a fraction of the cost of buying new machinery.

When repairing or rebuilding equipment, affordability and availability of parts are primary considerations. OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts are typically more expensive but ensure compatibility and quality. Aftermarket parts, often less costly, offer a wide range of options and can be a viable alternative if quality is comparable. Availability can vary, with OEM parts sometimes requiring longer lead times, while aftermarket parts might be more readily accessible.

Time Investment: Maintenance vs. Replacement

The time investment for heavy equipment maintenance varies based on the task complexity:

1. Basic Maintenance: 

Tasks like oil changes, filter replacement and lubrication are relatively quick and can be completed in a few hours, minimizing downtime.

2. Intermediate Maintenance: 

These operations include belt and hose replacements, which could take a day or more, depending on part availability.

3. Advanced Maintenance: 

Comprehensive tasks like engine overhauls or hydraulic system repairs are time-intensive, potentially requiring several days to weeks, especially if parts are not readily available.

Lead times for new equipment can vary significantly, often extending to weeks or even months due to production schedules, supply chain issues and demand fluctuations. Equipment availability can be challenging with global supply chain disruptions and heightened demand that has increased wait times and limited stock. Purchasing new equipment may require planning well in advance, with the flexibility to consider alternatives or temporary solutions.

Best Practices for Construction Equipment Maintenance

Scheduled Maintenance

Adhering to manufacturer-recommended scheduled maintenance involves regular, planned servicing, such as fluid checks and lubrication of moving parts. It ensures that heavy machinery operates efficiently and reliably, minimizing unexpected breakdowns by identifying minor issues before they escalate into major problems. Having your particular machine’s service manual on-hand can help you know exactly when to replace or service a component. Typical maintenance intervals for heavy equipment, often outlined in the manufacturer's manual, provide a predictable and reliable schedule, giving you a sense of control and security. These schedules generally follow these patterns:

• Daily Checks: Basic walkaround inspections, cleaning, lubrication and checking fluid levels to ensure safe operation.
• Weekly Maintenance: More thorough checks of components like filters, belts and safety devices.
• Monthly or 250-Hour Intervals: Includes oil changes, hydraulic fluid checks and detailed inspection of moving parts for wear and damage.
• Annual or 1,000-Hour Intervals: Comprehensive evaluation and servicing, such as replacing parts, significant fluid changes and testing engine and electrical systems.

High-Quality Replacement Parts

Using high-quality replacement parts, whether OEM or reliable aftermarket, is crucial for maintaining a machine's efficiency and longevity. These heavy equipment parts ensure compatibility, reducing the risk of operational failures.

Investing in reliable parts can prevent frequent breakdowns, minimize downtime and ensure the machinery performs optimally, ultimately extending the machine's life and reducing long-term costs.

Training Operators

Training operators to recognize potential issues and perform daily maintenance is vital for preventing significant failures. They should be able to identify abnormal vibrations, unusual noises, fluid leaks, belt wear and warning signal issues. Skilled operators enhance equipment reliability by addressing minor problems early, ensuring safety and reducing unplanned downtime.

Documentation

Companies should keep thorough maintenance and repair records to track the history and performance of each machine, enabling informed decision-making on replacements or upgrades. Detailed records help identify recurring issues, optimize maintenance schedules and ensure regulatory compliance. They also enhance resale value by demonstrating diligent care and validating warranty claims. Comprehensive documentation ultimately supports cost control and improves overall fleet management efficiency.

Facts to Consider When Deciding to Replace Heavy Equipment

When deciding to replace equipment, consider the following factors:

• Machine's Age: Older machines may require more frequent repairs, affecting reliability and cost-effectiveness. A typical excavator has a lifespan of about 10,000 hours, while a wheel loader could last even longer, about 12,000 hours. However, frequent repairs and refurbishment can increase your equipment’s odds of lasting longer than the typical machine.
• Frequency of Breakdowns: Frequent malfunctions increase downtime and repair costs, indicating a need for replacement.
• Technological Advancements: Newer models may offer improved efficiency and safety features, potentially justifying an upgrade.
• Maintenance Costs: High maintenance expenses can outweigh the benefits of keeping current equipment.
• Operational Demands: Determine whether existing equipment meets current and future operational requirements.
• Resale Value: Decide if selling the old equipment can subsidize a new purchase.

Final Thoughts on Heavy Equipment Maintenance vs Replacing Equipment

Regular maintenance provides several key benefits that help avoid costly equipment replacements. By preventing wear and tear, it extends the lifespan of heavy machinery, ensuring it remains in service longer. Routine maintenance is also more cost-effective than emergency repairs or replacements. It helps minimize downtime by addressing issues before they lead to major breakdowns. Well-maintained equipment operates more efficiently, boosting performance, while regular checks improve workplace safety by preventing dangerous malfunctions. Additionally, equipment that has been consistently maintained often has a higher resale value.

The EquipmentShare Shop sells OEM and aftermarket heavy equipment parts for various machine types. Get fast shipping on the replacement components your equipment needs to get back to working condition, avoiding extended downtime and major equipment failure in the process. Don’t see the exact part your machine needs? Reach out to our dedicated parts experts and get personalized assistance.

Home > Machine Maintenance