Gaskets vs O-Rings: What’s the Difference?
Gaskets vs O-Rings: What’s the Difference?
Reading time: 5 min
Gaskets and O-rings are two common types of seals found in heavy equipment. While they both perform the important function of sealing mating surfaces—preventing liquid or gas from escaping—they are quite different in design and function.
O-rings are actually a type of gasket, but they are made from elastomer and are donut-shaped. O-rings fit into a groove between two round mating surfaces and provide a tight seal between components. In heavy equipment, they are commonly used throughout a machine, especially in the hydraulic system.
Gaskets, unlike O-rings, are flat seals that can be made from a variety of materials. While they are typically round, gaskets can come in any shape. Gaskets can be found throughout heavy equipment—and are used in diesel engines and heavy equipment exhaust systems.
While the differences between the two types of seals may seem subtle, they are not interchangeable. Certain components require gaskets, while others require O-rings.
In this guide, we’ll explore the differences and similarities between these important seals, and how they affect heavy equipment performance.
What Are Gaskets Used For?
Some common heavy equipment applications for gaskets include:
- Engine cylinder heads: Gaskets are used between the engine block and the cylinder head to provide a seal and maintain compression within the combustion chamber.
- Exhaust systems: Gaskets are used in exhaust manifolds, flanges and connections to prevent gas leaks and maintain proper sealing between exhaust components.
- Pipe connections: Gaskets are used in various pipe connections, such as flange connections, to create a seal between pipes and prevent fluid or gas leakage.
- Transmission components: Gaskets are used in transmission pans, valve bodies and other transmission components to provide sealing and prevent fluid leaks.
- Cooling system components: Gaskets are used in radiator connections, water pump housing and thermostat housing to ensure proper sealing in the cooling system.
What Are O-Rings Used For?
Some common heavy equipment applications for O-rings include:
- Hydraulic cylinders: O-rings are used in the piston and rod seals of hydraulic cylinders to prevent fluid leakage and maintain pressure.
- Valves: O-rings are used in various types of valves—such as control valves, relief valves and directional valves to provide sealing between moving parts.
- Pumps: O-rings are used in hydraulic pumps, fuel pumps and water pumps to create a seal between the pump housing and internal components.
- Sealing joints: O-rings are used in joints and connections between pipes, hoses and fittings in hydraulic systems to prevent fluid leakage.
- Rotating shafts: O-rings are used as rotary shaft seals to prevent the leakage of lubricants or contaminants in rotating components like gearboxes and axles.
Similarities and Differences Between Gaskets and O-Rings
Similarities
Since they are both seals, gaskets and O-rings serve the function of sealing the mating surface between two components.
Both gaskets and O-rings rely on compression to form an air- or liquid-tight seal. As the seal is compressed between the two mating surfaces, the seal expands inside the joint, filling the irregularities between the surfaces.
They are commonly used in heavy equipment to ensure reliable sealing in applications such as hydraulic systems, engine components, pipe connections and more.
Differences
Despite having much in common, O-rings and gaskets are still quite different.
Importantly, O-rings feature a higher level of compression than gaskets. Since they are made from elastomer, O-rings are better at expanding between two mating surfaces, providing a seal that is better suited to handling high pressure.
Due to their design, O-rings also require a groove in order to function properly. This sets them apart from gaskets, as gaskets are used for joining two flat surfaces that do not feature a groove.
Compared to O-rings, gasket designs are far more diverse. Since they do not require a groove, gaskets are not restricted to circle-shaped designs. In fact, many gaskets are shaped like squares and rectangles. For example, heavy equipment exhaust gaskets are commonly square or rectangular.
While O-rings are better for high-pressure applications, like in hydraulic cylinders, gaskets are better in high-temperature environments. Since gaskets can be made from a wide variety of materials, including polymers and metals, they are more versatile in their uses.
O-Rings Overview
Since they offer an excellent seal in high-pressure conditions, O-rings are common throughout a machine’s hydraulic system. For example, a machine’s hydraulic cylinders feature a number of dynamic O-ring seals that contain the hydraulic fluid and manage its egress from out of the cylinders.
Other locations you’ll find O-rings on your machine include the machine’s engine and cooling systems, where they play a key role in maintaining liquid seals between components.
O-rings for heavy equipment are commonly made from materials such as nitrile rubber (NBR), fluorocarbon rubber (FKM), silicone rubber (VMQ), or ethylene propylene diene monomer (EPDM).
It’s crucial to select the right material O-ring for your application to ensure proper sealing and longevity. Using an incompatible O-ring can result in premature failure, leaks, reduced performance and potential damage to the equipment.
O-rings are incredibly inexpensive, and commonly cost in the range of $5-10. However, some O-rings in critical systems need to be replaced by a professional, adding to the replacement cost.
Gaskets Overview
In heavy equipment, gaskets are most commonly found in a machine’s engine. For example, a machine’s head gasket, found in the engine, seals the cylinder head to the engine block.
Other types of gaskets include valve cover gaskets, exhaust gaskets and intake gaskets.
Gaskets can be made from different materials, depending on the location of the gasket and its desired function. The choice of material impacts the gasket’s performance and ability to withstand high temperatures and pressure.
In general, gaskets are inexpensive, though some gaskets require professional assistance to be replaced. A typical replacement gasket for heavy equipment engines costs in the range of $10-$100.
Conclusion
Seals, including O-rings and gaskets, are critical to heavy equipment performance. They help keep liquid and gas contained in hoses, tanks, cylinders and other components.
Maintaining your machine’s O-rings and gaskets may be important, but it doesn’t need to be challenging. The EquipmentShare Parts Shop has a wide variety of O-rings and gaskets available for purchase online.
Our selection of O-rings and gaskets includes parts for popular heavy equipment manufacturers such as Takeuchi, Sany and Wacker Neuson. Need help choosing the right O-ring or gasket? Contact one of our parts experts and get personalized assistance.